hms iron duke

hms iron duke

Monday, 8 April 2013

North Korea: Sad, Bad and Mad?

Alphen, Netherlands. 8 April.  In 2000 Cranfield University’s Professor Helen Smith posed the now seminal question about North Korea, “Bad, Mad, Sad or Rational Actor?” Kim Jong-un, the thirty-ish leader of the somewhat mis-nomered Democratic People’s Republic of Korea (DPRK) would indeed seem on the face of it to be bad, mad and sad.  On 13 March, 2013 Pyongyang unilaterally abrogated the July 1953 Armistice that ended the 1950-1953 Korean War, last week the military was apparently given the go-ahead to begin military operations and Seoul thinks North Korea will conduct its fourth nuclear test at its Punggye-ri testing site this coming Wednesday.  But is the DPRK really bad, mad and sad?
 
Rather than involve myself in the usual shark-infested ‘analyst’ media feeding frenzy such occasions generate I took a step back and over the past week spoke to several senior people with real knowledge of DPRK (as much as that is possible) in search of policy perspective.  Several common themes emerged.
1.           Honouring the ancestor:  Kim Jong-un may be trying to honour his grandfather and DPRK’s founder Kim Il-sung by trying to re-generate some ‘ideological’ fervour in the run up to the 27 July sixtieth anniversary of the Armistice that halted the Korean War.
2.           Remembering Stalin: March saw the sixtieth anniversary of Josef Stalin’s death.  This anniversary may have also contributed to the search for renewal of the world’s last Stalinist state with Kim consciously trying to re-create the Stalinist cult of the leader.
3.           “Military First”: Kim’s father, Kim Jong-il, crafted the policy of “Songun” or “military-first”.  This oppressive regime in which much of its population is starving or close to starving is kept going by a close system of patronage between the governing dynasty and the military top brass.  Certainly, if Kim loses the support of the military he is finished and he may well be demonstrating his commitment to them.
4.           China is shifting:  Chinese President Xi has made it clear Beijing is no longer willing to tolerate the racketeering and other practices of the dynasty it has hitherto supported.  This weekend President Xi came as close to issuing a warning to its long-time ally as Beijing has ever uttered.  Irritated by the constant war rhetoric Xi said, “No-one should be allowed to throw a region and even the whole world into chaos for selfish reasons”.  Critically, China is also building ever closer trade relations with the Republic of Korea (South Korea) which is known to concern Pyongyang.  
5.           Kim Jong-un believes: Kim Il-sung once famously said (famous at least in DPRK), “We are opposed to the line of compromise with imperialism. At the same time, we cannot tolerate the practice of shouting against imperialism, but in actual fact being afraid to fight it”.  Worryingly, Kim Jong-un may actually believe this to be true.
There can be no question that all of the above considerations are exercising the minds of the small policy clique close to Kim Jong-un who are normally quite considered in the actions they advise.  However, perhaps the most intriguing possibility is that this whole crisis may have been triggered by the well-intentioned, but perhaps naive private diplomacy of American basketball star Denis Rodman.  At the end of February Mr Rodman made a surprise visit to Pyongyang.  It is known that in a meeting with Mr Rodman Kim Jong-un said he wanted a direct face-to-face meeting with President Obama. 
Such a meeting would be in line with Pyongyang’s long-standing demand that any negotiations for a final peace treaty be conducted directly with Washington rather than with the six-party Contact Group or through the UN.  Moreover, one of my contacts also suggested that Kim may have placed a lot of political capital on Rodman’s visit seeing it as something akin to the Nixon-Kissinger “Ping-Pong Diplomacy” in 1971 by which Beijing and Washington signalled to each other the desire for a new era in US-China relations.
Therefore, the current stand-off just could be the result of Kim losing face with the military over Rodman’s visit.  Here’s the rub; in spite of the current nuclear foot-stamping the ruling dynasty could be signalling that it wants a formal peace treaty with the US (and not the Contact Group) prior to the July anniversary of the Armistice or at least an agreement by Washington to begin negotiations by then.  A peace treaty would both remove DPRK's inherent and constant sense of vulnerability and guarantee the regime’s survival.  In other words, this crisis could eventually lead to an opportunity.
Even if half correct Kim would be taking a very big risk with the military and may need to prove his hard-line credentials prior to any peace move.  Washington clearly understands this bigger picture and intelligently cancelled an unrelated, routine missile test over the weekend.
North Korea; sad, bad but perhaps not completely mad.
Julian Lindley-French

5 comments:

  1. Most Adventure and Challenging Everest Base Camp Trek which is popular all over in the world, The Everest Trekking Routes will daily departure as 10 to 14 Days EBC Trekking as Multi routes Everest Three high Pass, Everest Gokyo lake, Jiri to Everest Base Camp and Everest Cho la Pass. Amazing scenery above 8000 meters top of the world and white Himalayan snow covered peaks.
    Those who are real travel to do mainly focusing Everest Base Camp and try to summit 8848 m. challenging Expedition. Moderate and high adventure Trekking routes khumbu region border of Nepal and Tibet high Himalayan ranges, now daily update all accommodation and foods choice of trekkers reliable various dishes and luxury trip maker and custom trip Designing. High qualified Trekking guide team and local base training Porter with Reasonable Cost Travel packages operate since 1997 as professional Mountain Guide Team. If anyone interest to visit everest trekking routes link https://www.everesttrekkingroutes.com

    ReplyDelete
  2. The high 5 Adventures is Expedition Company in Nepal. So Mr Narbin Magar has been selected for the All Trekking peaks and Expedition leading since 2005 to till Local Base Expedition Agency in Nepal. Most of the Challenging Trekking Agency which is popular peak Climbing, Trekking in Nepal and Expedition in Nepal, the High 5 Adventures Company all Staff are has been trained Mountaineering and enough Strong Local guide and Climbing Sherpa’s. Everest Expedition Company is one of the most challenging and high light Trekking routes in Nepal. Everest base camp, Langtang Trekking, manaslu trekking, Annapurna base camp, Annapurna Circuit, Dhaulagiri round and many others Trekking routes in Nepal. The part of the Peak climbing and Expedition is more attractive and Adventures Expedition in Nepal.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Car Hire Nepal, Tourism is one of the major industries in Nepal which make offer an opportunity to see the beautiful scenery and the wonderful scenery of the mountain. We are famous for fast, secure and efficient door-to-door service. Renting the car in Nepal provides you freedom and flexibility wherever you traveling. It is providing the best service along with the less fare and better service. During the journey is seriously valuable for us about their comfort. Nepal is an ancient country with many attractions for travelers. It gives a wholesome holiday experience because of its diversity and you can find a new meaning to life with your trip to this wonderful land. A Nepal tour has the cheapest service in Kathmandu. We are proud to offer the visitor with the affordable bus fares along with the stander and comfortable service. This service offers you a wide range of great deal and services whenever you want to rent a car.
    Car Hire Nepal, We offer competitive price and up-to-date information; ensuring quality and efficiency for our entire visit at all times. We offer a wide variety of vehicles rental service in Nepal. We wish to make your stay as comfortable and memorable as possible. If you enjoy touring, we will be able to provide you with information on the many beautiful sights in our wonderful city. We can offer you the service of the experienced driver and supply you the maps and helpful information about your expeditions. The road of Nepal in the Himalayan region like off road and car is the best vehicles to drive. You may ask our driver if you want to stop for a while if you want to have lunch or tea or rest during your driver. Our objective is to continually improve the car rental service in Nepal while offering our customers a cost-effective service.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Nepal Base Camp Treks coming this 2018 to 2019 highly recommend as Everest Base Camp Trek give you full board packages and Details Everest Base Camp Trek Itinerary and Everest Base Camp Trek Cost. Those trip are customized as Everest Base Camp trek 12 days and Everest Base Camp Trek 14 days. which is suitable for you and can make your desire. The trip starts from Lukla to Namche and all the way to Everest base camp trek route. there are some place has high altitude and Everest Base Camp Trek ifficulty and if you are looking you can read first Everest Base Camp Trek reviews.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Annapurna Base Camp Trek start pokhara to ghorepani poon hill and continue to ABC Trekking, this trip can complete Annapurna Base Camp Trek 7 days as well and Also if have enough time can make Annapurna Base Camp Trek 10 days. Annapurna Base Camp Trek route is very beautiful and Perfect Himalayan scenery. the only make Annapurna Base Camp trek difficulty. June to August and JanuaryFebruary.Annapurna Base Camp Trek distance is around 200 miles. there are many Travel has been read Annapurna Base Camp Trek blog. September to

    November is one of the Best Season makes the trek to Annapurna Base Camp.

    ReplyDelete