November 18. Putin is about to have his Yalta moment. This week in Shenzhen, China he will be photographed with Trump and Xi at the first Trilateral Summit. On the face of it Putin will be very much Churchill to Roosevelt and Stalin, the leader of a fading country who is there more out of politesse than power., but that is not the point. In February 1945 at Yalta in Crimea (!!!!), Roosevelt and Stalin carved up Europe whilst Churchill quietly fumed in the margins at how reduced Britain had become as a power. There will be much talk about a new European security architecture. Putin probably really believes there is a chance that Trump and Xi will agree to a new carving up Europe through the agency of the American and Chinese power. That begs three questions: what does Putin really want, how will he try and get it, and what is the plan?
What does Putin really want? Putin is both a predator and opportunist. He believes that mistrust between the Trump administration and most Europeans is now so deep that opportunity beckons to build a new virtual Iron Curtain from Kaliningrad in the north, to Trieste in the south.
How will Putin get what he wants? First, the most important thing for Putin is the optics of negotiating with Trump and Xi. He is in the room negotiating over their heads whilst Europeans are locked outside. The immediate issue at hand will be ending the war in Ukraine but that is not really what he wants. His grand strategic aim is to rebuild the former Soviet empire in Europe through occupation or coercion.
Second, Putin is using disinformation, destabilisation, deception, mass disruption and implied mass destruction to first decouple America from European defence. Putin is also pressuring ill-prepared, politically weak and economically challenged Western European states from intervening through NATO to force those who live east of Putin’s new Ion Curtain into this new Russian sphere of AI influence.
The plan is as old as Russia itself. Last week Putin issued an Invader’s Charter. A policy paper established Putin’s demands to agree a ceasefire in Ukraine, and the effective subjugation of central and eastern Europe. Putin not only wants all of Russia’s ill-gotten gains in Ukraine confirmed, but he also wants Kyiv divided with Russian control extending to the Dnieper River. Putin would thus gain control of the great breadbasket of Europe, the most economically most productive regions of Ukraine. In return, he would allow rump Ukraine to join the EU. He also demands that Finland leaves NATO, and that all Allied forces are withdrawn from much of eastern Europe and the Baltic States back to pre-1997 positions. Critically, Putin demanded that Britain and France also withdraw their nuclear umbrella over NATO members.
Cue Putin’s Chinese Yalta. In his excellent book Moscow Rules, my friend and fellow member of The Alphen Group, Keir Giles, describes how Moscow negotiates: begin with a series of outrageous demands and then over time grudgingly accept 50% of them, but only grudgingly so that grievances can be maintained for future use.
Putin’s systemic struggle with the West is not really a struggle with the West. It is a struggle between Russian Europe and the rest of Europe. It is only a struggle with the Americans by extension. In Putin’s mind it is really a struggle with the most ‘powerful’ Europeans, Britain, France and Germany. The reason he thinks he may succeed is that he thinks he has the implied support of both a rotten Administration in Washington and his fellow rapacious autocrat Xi in Beijing. Above all, his adversaries, Britain, France and Germany, have made themselves rotten powers, politically vacuous, strategically inept, financially indebted and militarily hollowed-out.
The real enemy is continuing denial in Berlin, London and Paris about the threat Putin poses to them. For Putin his war is both existential and ideological. Existential because having started it if he loses, he is dead. Ideological because it is two competing ideas of power born of European history. A struggle between those who believe that Europeans should have the right to self-determine their alliances and allegiances and Putin’s belief that the powerful do as they do and the weak do as they must in a re-established and extended Russian sphere of influence.
To punish Putin and counter Trump Europeans must do the one thing they find so hard: invest strategy with power not words. The best way Europeans can help Ukraine is to do unto Caesar what Caesar doeth unto them. This means not only building up their own armed forces far more, but they must also go on the offensive and attack Russia across the information and cyber space. If they do that it will soon become apparent that Putin is no Stalin and that much of his power is illusory and far from being able to divide and rule, he can only divide and fool.
Julian Lindley-French, Emeritus Chairman, The Alphen Group
